Sen. Hatch To Bernanke: Keep Your Advice To Yourself

Posted by Orb Staff on January 11, 2012 No Comments
Categories : Residential Mortgage

10691_220px-orrin_hatch_official_110th_congress_photo Sen. Hatch To Bernanke: Keep Your Advice To Yourself Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, ranking member of the Senate Finance Committee, severely criticized a 26-page white paper on proposed housing policy reforms that the Federal Reserve unexpectedly submitted to Congress last week.

In a letter to Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke, Hatch warned that the Fed was treading ‘too far into fiscal policy advice and advocacy’ and was offering the impression that the central bank risked ‘being perceived as advocacy for particular policy options.’

‘Many in Congress have had sympathy for the Fed's belief that its forays into the fiscal space were necessary to address the financial crisis,’ Hatch wrote to Bernanke. ‘However, I believe that your recent housing white paper, and recent advocacy by Federal Reserve officials for further taxpayer-funded government 'intervention' in housing and mortgage markets, intrudes too far into fiscal policy advice and advocacy. Indeed, one Fed official called putback rules of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac as 'excessively stringent.' Such comments seem, to me, to be out of bounds.’

Hatch also noted that the Fed has done its share in bringing more tumult to an already-shaky economy.

‘Moreover,’ he continued, ‘the Fed created a number of programs that allocated credit to narrowly defined sectors and classes of borrowers (e.g., commercial paper, asset-backed securities, money market mutual funds) despite clearly stating in a March 23, 2009 joint statement with the Treasury that such allocation should not be your aim and that: 'Government decisions to influence the allocation of credit are the province of the fiscal authorities.' The Fed, nonetheless, continued to purchase housing agency mortgage-backed securities and agency debt to increase credit availability and reduce the cost of credit in the housing market.

‘Because many of those Fed activities involved government intervention into private markets and government assumption of private risks on behalf of taxpayers,’ Hatch added, ‘I believe they constituted bailouts and fiscal policy actions, independent of whether the Fed ends up making money or losing money. The Fed is not a hedge fund, and profit and loss on its extraordinary asset purchases are not the appropriate metric by which to judge the efficacy of those actions. Many Fed actions led to increased moral hazard, which will unfortunately persist.’

Register here to receive our Latest Headlines email newsletter




Leave a Comment