in News > Mortgage Servicing
print the content item


A former Fannie Mae executive is warning that plans being considered by several California localities to use eminent-domain laws for seizing and refinancing underwater mortgages will create more problems than solutions.

"This use of eminent domain will face serious legal challenges, and any attempt at implementation is fraught with problems," says Edward Pinto, former executive vice president, chief credit officer and senior vice president of marketing and product management at Fannie Mae and a resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), a Washington, D.C.-based think tank. "It certainly is not the free lunch being pitched to localities."

Pinto warns that legal problems may arise over whether eminent domain is being invoked for public use, adding that this could be litigated in the courts for years. He also stresses that the seizure of property has repercussions if the mortgages have been securitized.

"It strikes at the heart of the contractual relationship underpinning the securitization of mortgages and the relationship between lender and borrower," he says. "As with many of the actions that have been taken that are anti-investor, this will materially impact investors’ willingness to buy private mortgage-backed securities and to risk the capital needed to support these securities.

"Since this plan would be implemented locally," Pinto adds, "investors could decide not to invest in securities from these areas, raising rates for many borrowers in the effected localities, thereby making matters worse. This approach would be on top of other anti-investor actions. For example, private investors were not a party to the states' attorneys general national mortgage settlement, which provided for principle reduction paid from investor funds."

Pinto also states that eminent domain seizure is predicated on the pessimistic belief that none of the loans being targeted for government takeover will ever be paid off.

"This is akin to buying a right-of-way for a limited-access highway and condemning the more valuable portion of a property that fronts a road, but valuing that frontage based on lower non-frontage rates," he says. "Fundamental fairness would prohibit such cherry picking."


Interthinx has Your Blueprint for Quality_1375


Latest Top Stories

Uniting For Quality Appraisals

How AMCs and appraisers are collaborating to ensure accurate, quality property valuations.


Five Things Servicers Can Do Now To Improve Customer Satisfaction

It's a worthy goal, not just because it will satisfy regulators but also because it can yield measurable savings for the servicer's contact center.


Fannie, Freddie Lower Down Payment Requirements

The GSEs are now accepting conventional mortgages with a down payment of as little as 3%.


Zillow: First-Time Home Buyers Will Lead Recovery In 2015

Stan Humphries, chief economist for Zillow, says he expects "the allure of fixed mortgage payments and a more stable housing market will entice many more otherwise content renters into the housing market."


New Home Sales Rose Slightly In October

It was the fifth consecutive month that the U.S. Census Bureau and U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development downwardly revised the previous month's new home sales estimate.

Urban Lending_id1351
Hse SandyHook
Industry Resource
Orb Mobile
MBA-TX_id
SWBC_id1313